Tim Burton – Victims of Sharia

By • on January 17, 2014
The West Midlands region of the United Kingdom

The West Midlands region of the United Kingdom


Slander (ghiba) – Reliance of the Traveller (page 730, r2.2); and Talebearing (namima) – Reliance of the Traveller (page 731, r2.3).


Freedom of expression.


Universal Declaration of Human Rights Article 19 (freedom of opinion and expression); European Convention of Human Rights Article 10 (freedom of expression); United States Constitution First Amendment (freedom of expression).


Liberty GB


Liberty GB states the following on its website:

‘Last week Liberty GB radio host, Tim Burton, was charged by West Midlands Police with racially aggravated harassment, after his post on Twitter described a prominent individual as “a mendacious grievance-mongering taqiyya-artist”.’ (for more details see the Liberty GB website)

Mr Burton was clearly expressing a personal opinion and should therefore be protected under the right to freedom of expression that Britons supposedly still enjoy.  Also the issue of truth was not mentioned and to the best of our knowledge no legal proceedings have been initiated on grounds of defamation.  Of course we are not making a judgement here about whether the remarks were true or false – that would be a matter for the civil courts.

The apparent heavy handed and overzealous approach of the UK police is especially worrying in that it may discourage people in the public eye, who make decisions effecting society, from being held to account – something that is essential in any functioning democracy.  If this sort of official action is allowed by current hate crime legislation then it is clear that such legislation is in desperate need of review if the UK is to meet its international human rights obligations.

The fact that the Mr Burton has been charged suggests that sharia norms are increasingly becoming embedded into British society at the expense of traditional conceptions of law and justice.  However, sharia is not been implemented openly and honestly, but by stealth, often via ill-defined and broadly applied ‘hate crime’ regulations.

It would appear that Mr Burton has become a victim of sharia, just like victims of bulling and persecution in many Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) member states where sharia provision are applied more directly.  The specific sharia concepts that appear to be being implemented in this case in the UK are the concepts of slander (ghiba) and talebearing (namima).

The Islamic concept of slander is very different to what Western law recognises (see http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/slander).  Western legal systems tend to require a statement in question to be untrue.  However, under sharia truth is irrelevant.  The well respected manual of sharia law, Reliance of the Traveller refers to slander and talebearing in the following terms:

“Slander (ghiba) means to mention anything concerning a person that he would dislike, whether about his body, religion, everyday life, self, disposition, son father, wife, servant, turban, garment, gait, movements, smiling, dissoluteness, frowning, cheerfulness, or anything else concerning him.” (page 730, r2.2)

“As for talebearing (namima), it consists of quoting someone’s words to another in a way that worsens relations between them.” (page 731, r2.3)

It therefore appears that in the United Kingdom, the Islamic concepts of slander and talebearing are being subsumed under the broad and ill-defined heading of ‘hate’.  It appears that public authorities are treating non-Muslims as second class citizens, something else that sharia demands.  This means that in a very stealthy and underhand manner the United Kingdom is sidestepping its obligations under international law with regard to the most basic of human rights.

In places like Pakistan such legal provisions are regularly used to persecute religious minorities. It is unfortunate that UK policy makers are either not doing due diligence when legislating or are legislating to deliberately undermine basic freedoms.


ICLA believes that freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free and democratic society.  It also believes that religious and other minorities, or indeed anyone, should not be subject to discrimination and persecution and that sensible legislation that respects basic human rights is required to ensure this.  We recognise the necessity for and the considerable advantages that are derived from different cultures to working together in an increasingly globalised world.  However, in the interests of basic human rights and equality before the law, it does not believe that incorporating sharia principles into the legal system is the answer.  Sharia results in religious persecution and is therefore not something that should ever be used as a solution in any just and democratic society.  The division of the world into Muslim and Non-Muslim that is stipulated by sharia does not serve the interests of a just and cohesive society and risks creating greater division and bad feeling.  Our goal is to create a just society where people are both free to express themselves while at the same time being free from persecution and intimidation.  We therefore seek to work with people and organisations from across the religious and cultural spectrum who also want to improve community cohesion and ensure a just and happy society.

We therefore make the following recommendations:

1) That in the interests of justice and to ensure that the UK meetings its international human rights obligations the petty and politically motivated charges against Mr Burton be dropped.

2) That the British Government reviews all its hate crime legislation to ensure that fundamental principles of justice are not undermined.  Vague regulations need to be replaced by ones that are well defined and that can be easily understood by the general public and by law enforcement professionals.

3) That all stakeholders come together to help create a just and cohesive society.


The International Civil Liberties Alliance recommends activists to do the following:

1) If you are in the UK then you should write to your Member of Parliament about this issue cite the above Liberty GB quote above (including a link to it).  Ask them whether they personally believe that scarce police resources are used in this way to undermine freedom of expression rather than serve the interests of justice.  You may also like to ask them whether they are in favour of reform of hate crime legislation to prevent overzealous policing that is evident in this particular case.  Contact details for MPs can be found HERE.

2) If you are in another country you should write to the British Ambassador or High Commissioner in your country citing the Liberty GB quote above (including a link to it).  You should also ask them whether human rights abuse implied by this this sort of incident could impact negatively on the relations between your country and the UK.  Do the state sponsored abuses suffered by people like Tim Burton indicate that Britain is no longer the land of freedom of expression that it purports to be when lecturing other countries.  Contact details can be found via the following: https://www.gov.uk/government/world/organisations

Remember to be polite and respectful in all your communications.


More information about VOSAN can be found HERE.

  • GeorgeWhale

    Excellent article, thank you Aeneas.

    Report this comment

  • Chris Knowles

    Thanks for your comment George – I really think that West Midlands Police have seriously abused their power in this case.

    Report this comment

  • Chris Knowles

    This case will something for ICLA to raise at the OSCE Human Dimension meeting in Warsaw in the autumn. UK authorities seem to be regularly crossing the line and violating their international obligations on a regular basis while at the same time lecturing other countries. The UK’s human rights abuses are subtle, but no less real. UK authorities are in serious need of international supervision with regard to the regular human rights abuses that are committed in the UK under the camouflage of smoke and mirrors!

    Report this comment

  • mzungu

    Wow it would be great if the police would listen in on some of the ‘Asian’ men talking about the wonderful and law abiding citizens of the UK. In all fairness their ‘Asian’ religion teaches white-O’-phobia, Western Hate, murder, judgement, persecution and execution. My recommendation is the police find someone who can read Persian/Arabic script and do some snooping and some detainment, arresting, fining and deporting in that area. Shall we?

    Report this comment

  • Hoover2630

    Similar to the Jewel sandals, Tara sandals would also give you that fabulous look. You can wear this pair to a dressy event while you are on your hot bike. These sandals are made with full grain leather and a cushioned foot sole.Looking back, the Patriots werent as good as their record, and at this point of their schedule they were prime for a letdown game against a team perceived to be bad. The Browns, after stumbling through some tough early http://www.topshoesbay.com/nike-blazer-low-c-76/ season loses, werent as bad as their record and at home coming off a bye with a head coach intimately familiar with their upcoming opponent, it should have been pretty clear that they had a good chance to come out victorious. And they did.

    1% yield. What more, the company has raised its dividend for 18 years (and counting). Bottom line: During challenging economic times, consumers flock to outlet stores.2003: 3 – 3 Playoffs – Super Bowl – Winner2002: 4 – 1 Playoffs – Super Bowl – Winner2001: 2 -1 Playoffs – Super Bowl – WinnerMore specifically, primaries and caucuses are means of selecting delegates (representatives of party members in each state) to send to the party’s national convention.- At each party’s national convention (held the summer before the presidential election), the party selects a presidential nominee based on how party delegates at the convention vote. The Republican and Democratic parties in each state select delegates based on either caucuses or a primary vote in that state — the delegates are sent to represent voters in the state.

    How to Deliver Bad NewsThese delays buy us a reprieve, but they surely don improve the situation. In fact, as we hesitate, prevaricate, and beat around the bush, the underlying problem gets worse and the web of complications grows ever more tangled.Although 2010 ended with a sour note the Bobcats have a lot to look forward to. Recently, basketball legend Michael Jordan was approved to become the majority owner of the Charlotte Bobcats. Jordan is known for his competitive nature and many people feel like he will go to whatever lengths necessary to bring this team to the top.I just decided to remove my RUBBISH NIC (wireless) here is a topic about it and how its mal-functioning.TP-Link network card ISSUESso i removed it and SURPRISE!

    Aus BrooksBlue,White,us65,us7,us75,us8,us85,us9,us95,us10,us11,b, Nike Free .Jul 31, 2013. Purchase AVIA Women A115W Cross-Training Shoe,White/Chrome Silver/ Detox Blue/Iron Grey,11 M US.Socks, on the other hand, are much like ties in the way you can be creative with them in matching them with your dress style.Unlike the women, men often do not feel the need to have shoes in all the colors of the rainbow. The most popular dress shoe color is black, followed by brown, burgundy, white, chestnut.You still wear a shirt of the NFL for the men. Now women NFL jerseys are available. You have to fit a woman, and often in the feminine colors like pink.I could figure out that these footwear rapidly became a warm item since they were released on the market. Mean whilst, Nike Blazer Low there comes a new shoes, Griffey shoes. There are individuals who go directly to the manufacturers of trainers and buy a quantity of them to market towards the open public straight.

    Designer labels like Louis Vuitton, Prada, Gucci and Burberry have their own laptop lines. Other brands and manufacturers most likely have their own bags for computers, too. These carrying cases won’t look out of place with your power suit or even an evening dress.Start by writing some quality content articles which are also keyword incorporated. There are a lot of people given the gift of being good with words. Writing comes easy for them.Our hotel’s western Pennsylvania location also provides easy access to Amish country. After a long day of meetings, sightseeing and shopping, our guests have a comfortable and contemporary hotel waiting. An indoor pool, whirlpool and sauna provide plenty of relaxation.

    Nike pas cher Shox made the debut with the previous Nationwide basketball association celebrity basketball gamer, Vince Billings, whose amazing dunk wearing Nike pas cher VC within the 2k Sidney Olympics created shox a story within the thoughts from the viewers Nike Free 7. This particular made certain the initial someone status associated with Vince Billings.Right now Nike Shox has changed into a fairly mature product kind, composed the earlier Shox VC, BB4, R4 CARD, R3 as well as the more recent Shox Ya Womens nike air force 1 mid Nike Free Run.These basics have turned Woodland into one of the best shoe manufacturer all across the world. If you want to have an immediate of look of woodland shoes collection, you can check on line. The company not only offers an online view of its collection but also offers facility to buy at home comfort.

    Report this comment